I've been holding off on this due to a slightly more busy work schedule this past week, but the results of the questionnaire indicate that the majority of people want the server wiped, pvp in the main world is split 50/50, a majority want the main world to not have a dynamic map enabled, people want Lioncloud Isles to stay, and a slight majority wanted old worlds accessible via spectator mode over survival.
Here's the plan: we can either get the new world up immediately, or I can make a backup of the current world (the Hinterlands, Newbank, Southbridge, and Serpent's Pass will become "museum worlds") so we can have one of those crazy pre-wipe celebrations we used to have. I'm thinking full creative mode, access to the NBTEditor plugin, and no regions? Lioncloud will be moved over as it is, with anything that can hold an inventory (chests, furnaces, etc.) being deleted.
Also, we now have two moderators who can mute, kick, and temp-ban anyone breaking our rules: mountainboy965 and Tsysin.
Edit: Bringing server down so I can transfer the worlds and get Debian to quit bugging me about updates.